Title

Combined Bleaching Technique: Efficacy and Tooth Sensitivity
Combined Bleaching Technique: Efficacy and Tooth Sensitivity - A Randomized, Double Blind Clinical Trial
  • Phase

    Phase 4
  • Study Type

    Interventional
  • Study Participants

    108
The aim of this clinical study is to evaluate the efficacy and dental sensitivity associated with Combined Bleaching Technique (in-office + at-home) varying in-office bleaching application under two different time protocols, and dentifrice containing arginine 8% and carbonate calcium use. One hundred eight participants who meet the study inclusion criteria will be selected. The desensitizing agent used will be a dentifrice containing 8% arginine and calcium carbonate. In each evaluation will be determined: tooth sensitivity and color. The data collected will be submitted to the factorial statistical analysis for evaluation of color and chi-square test for tooth sensitivity (α = 5%).
This study will be conducted under the CONSORT recommendations. After approval by the Ethics Committee for Research duly registered, the trial will be conducted in the clinic of dental school at the Federal University of Goias located in Goiania. One hundred eight participants 108 volunteers will be selected on the criteria that qualify inclusion and exclusion from the study will be reported all volunteers were examined not qualify under the criteria for inclusion as part of the initial according to CONSORT recommendations .

After signing the signed an informed consent form all volunteer participants will receive a dental prophylaxis with pumice and water in a rubber cups for the removal of extrinsic stains two weeks before the beginning of tooth whitening.
Study Started
Apr 01
2016
Primary Completion
Nov 30
2016
Study Completion
Dec 31
2018
Results Posted
Aug 05
2019
Last Update
Aug 05
2019

Procedure Combined Bleaching(2x20)

one clinical session with two applications of 35% hydrogen peroxide of 20 minutes each. 10% carbamide peroxide for two hours daily over the course of two weeks.

Procedure Combined Bleaching(2x20) with arginine

one clinical session with two applications of 35% hydrogen peroxide of 20 minutes each. 10% carbamide peroxide for two hours daily over the course of two weeks.

Procedure Combined Bleaching (1x20)

one clinical session with one application of 35% hydrogen peroxide of 20 minutes each. 10% carbamide peroxide for two hours daily over the course of two weeks.

Procedure Combined Bleaching(1x20) with arginine

one clinical session with one application of 35% hydrogen peroxide of 20 minutes each. 10% carbamide peroxide for two hours daily over the course of two weeks.

Drug 8% arginine and calcium carbonate

using during all the treatment.

  • Other names: dentifrice containing carbonate arginine

Combined Bleaching(2x20) Experimental

In-office: 35% hydrogen peroxide of 20 minutes each. At-home: 10% carbamide peroxide

Combined Bleaching(2x20) with arginine Experimental

Combined Bleaching(2x20) with arginine In-office: 35% hydrogen peroxide of 20 minutes each. At-home: 10% carbamide peroxide Desensitizing agent: dentifrice containing 8% arginine and calcium carbonate.

Combined Bleaching(1x20) Experimental

In-office: 35% hydrogen peroxide of 20 minutes each. At-home: 10% carbamide peroxide

Combined Bleaching(1x20) with arginine Experimental

Combined Bleaching(1x20) with arginine In-office: 35% hydrogen peroxide of 20 minutes each. At-home: 10% carbamide peroxide Desensitizing agent: dentifrice containing 8% arginine and calcium carbonate.

Criteria

Inclusion Criteria:

Upper and lower anterior teeth without restorations;
Upper and lower anterior teeth that have never undergone a bleaching procedure and are A2 or darker in color compared to the Vita Classical).

Exclusion Criteria:

Presence of primary and/or secondary carious lesion (s) on upper and lower anterior teeth;
Presence of non-carious lesions, such as abfraction, erosion and abrasion;
Presence of clinically visible cracks or defects of dental enamel on the dental surfaces of the upper and lower anterior teeth;
Use of fixed orthodontic appliances;
Presence of tooth sensitivity classified as equal to or greater than mild;
Presence of severe dental dimming;
Presence of parafunctional habits;
Presence of any oral pathology;
Smokers;
pregnant and lactating women

Summary

Combined Bleaching(2x20)

Combined Bleaching(2x20) With Arginine

Combined Bleaching(1x20)

Combined Bleaching(1x20) With Arginine

All Events

Event Type Organ System Event Term Combined Bleaching(2x20) Combined Bleaching(2x20) With Arginine Combined Bleaching(1x20) Combined Bleaching(1x20) With Arginine

Tooth Sensitivity (TS)

Tooth sensitivity (TS) was evaluated using a five-point rating scale (NRS), in which 0 = none (minimum value), 1 = mild, 2 = moderate, 3 = considerable, and 4 = severe (maximum value); and a visual analogue scale (VAS) in wich each participant placed a line perpendicular to a 10-cm-long line (on which 0 referred to "no pain" (minimum value) and 10 referred to "severe pain" (maximum value)). Tooth sensitivity (TS) was evaluated during bleaching, and up to 48 hours postbleaching. The worst TS score or numeric value obtained in each assessment was considered for statistical purposes. It was calculated an average to obtain the median.

Combined Bleaching(2x20)

Intensity of TS during bleaching (NRS scale)

1.0
score on a scale (Median)
Inter-Quartile Range: 0.0 to 1.0

Intensity of TS during bleaching (VAS scale)

0.8
score on a scale (Median)
Inter-Quartile Range: 0.0 to 8.0

Intensity of TS up to 48 hours (NRS scale)

Intensity of TS up to 48 hours (VAS scale)

Combined Bleaching(1x20)

Intensity of TS during bleaching (NRS scale)

1.0
score on a scale (Median)
Inter-Quartile Range: 1.0 to 1.0

Intensity of TS during bleaching (VAS scale)

0.9
score on a scale (Median)
Inter-Quartile Range: 0.0 to 4.0

Intensity of TS up to 48 hours (NRS scale)

Intensity of TS up to 48 hours (VAS scale)

Combined Bleaching(1x20) With Arginine

Intensity of TS during bleaching (NRS scale)

1.0
score on a scale (Median)
Inter-Quartile Range: 0.0 to 1.0

Intensity of TS during bleaching (VAS scale)

0.6
score on a scale (Median)
Inter-Quartile Range: 0.0 to 6.0

Intensity of TS up to 48 hours (NRS scale)

Intensity of TS up to 48 hours (VAS scale)

Combined Bleaching(2x20) With Arginine

Intensity of TS during bleaching (NRS scale)

Intensity of TS during bleaching (VAS scale)

0.3
score on a scale (Median)
Inter-Quartile Range: 0.0 to 8.0

Intensity of TS up to 48 hours (NRS scale)

Intensity of TS up to 48 hours (VAS scale)

Color Evaluation

Objective color evaluation: The shade was determined using spectrophotometer VITA Easyshade, in which the parameters L*, a*, and b*, in which L* represents the value from 0 (black) to 100 (white) and a* and b* represent the shade, where a* is the measurement along the red-green axis and b* is the measurement along the yellow-blue axis. The color alteration (ΔE) was determined by the differences between the values obtained at baseline and one month after the treatment, which was calculated with the formula: ΔE = [(ΔL *) 2 + (Δa *) 2 + (Δb *) 2]1/2. In the Outcome Measure Data Table it was presented Mean and Standard Deviation of the color alteration (ΔE) between Baseline vs one month after bleaching for each group.

Combined Bleaching(2x20)

8.28
percentage of color change (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.73

Combined Bleaching(2x20) With Arginine

8.18
percentage of color change (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.76

Combined Bleaching(1x20)

7.72
percentage of color change (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.61

Combined Bleaching(1x20) With Arginine

8.11
percentage of color change (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.76

Total

108
Participants

Age, Continuous

21.2
years (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.1

Race and Ethnicity Not Collected

0
Participants

Age, Categorical

Sex: Female, Male

Overall Study

Combined Bleaching(2x20)

Combined Bleaching(1x20)

Combined Bleaching(1x20) With Arginine

Combined Bleaching(2x20) With Arginine

Drop/Withdrawal Reasons

Combined Bleaching(2x20) With Arginine