Title

Flurbiprofen Tape for Treatment of Chronic Low Back Pain
A Multi-Center, Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Trial of Flurbiprofen Tape for Treatment of Chronic Low Back Pain
  • Phase

    Phase 2
  • Study Type

    Interventional
  • Intervention/Treatment

    flurbiprofen ...
  • Study Participants

    127
The purpose of this trial is to evaluate the analgesic efficacy and safety of flurbiprofen tape for chronic low back pain (lasting greater than 3 months).
This study is a multi-center, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study in patients with daily low back pain below the 12th thoracic vertebra of greater than 3 months duration. Patients also had an average daily pain score of 4 or greater on an 11-point categorical pain scale for the last 3 days of the baseline phase. The study began with a 14-day washout period of previously used pain medications. At the end of the 14-day baseline phase, patients were randomized to 1 of 4 treatments: Flurbiprofen tape applied once daily for 12 hours, Flurbiprofen tape applied once daily for 24 hours, placebo tape applied once daily for 12 hours, or placebo tape applied once daily for 24 hours. During the 7-day treatment phase, patients applied 2 treatment tapes once daily for 7 days. The tapes remained on for 12 or 24 hours of continuous treatment, depending on the treatment to which they were randomized. Patients were provided with rescue medication. After 7 days of tape treatment, patients returned to the clinic for a study exit visit.
Study Started
Oct 31
2007
Primary Completion
Jul 31
2008
Study Completion
Jul 31
2008
Results Posted
Oct 06
2016
Estimate
Last Update
Oct 06
2016
Estimate

Drug Placebo Tape (Arm 1)

Two placebo tapes (one on each side of the spine) were applied on the lower back area once daily for 7 days.

Drug Flurbiprofen Tape (Arm 2)

Two flurbiprofen tapes (one on each side of the spine) were applied on the lower back area once daily for 7 days. Each tape contained 31.5 mg flurbiprofen for a total daily dose of 63 mg.

Drug Placebo Tape (Arm 3)

Two placebo tapes (one on each side of the spine) were applied on the lower back area once daily for 7 days.

Drug Flurbiprofen Tape (Arm 4)

Two flurbiprofen tapes (one on each side of the spine) were applied on the lower back area once daily for 7 days. Each tape contained 31.5 mg flurbiprofen for a total daily dose of 63 mg.

Placebo Tape (Arm 1) Placebo Comparator

Placebo tape remained on for 12 hours of continuous treatment per day.

Flurbiprofen Tape (Arm 2) Experimental

Flurbiprofen tape remained on for 12 hours of continuous treatment per day.

Placebo Tape (Arm 3) Placebo Comparator

Placebo tape remained on for 24 hours of continuous treatment per day.

Flurbiprofen Tape (Arm 4) Experimental

Flurbiprofen tape remained on for 24 hours of continuous treatment per day.

Criteria

Inclusion Criteria:

male or female 18 to 80 years;
signed an informed consent;
daily LBP below the 12th thoracic vertebra of greater than 3 months' duration;
able to ambulate at least 100 meters;
in stable general health with laboratory values within normal limits
no evidence of drug abuse or residual opiates; determined by urine drug screening;
diagnosis of chronic LBP verified by medical records;
female patients must be postmenopausal (defined as 1 year without menses), physically incapable of becoming pregnant, or using an acceptable birth control method. Non-postmenopausal patients must have confirmation of a negative urine pregnancy test;
must read and speak English;
must be reliable and mentally competent to complete study measurements;
must be available for the study visits and telephone checks from study entry to study completion.
male patients must use an acceptable method of birth control with their female partners;
rates their pain at 3 or higher on an 11-point Categorical Pain Scale for LBP over the prior week (7 days) of Visit 1.
over the last 3 days of the Baseline Phase, had a computed average pain score of 4 or greater on an 11-point Categorical Pain Scale
discontinued the use of any topical pain medications, salves, anticonvulsants, oral NSAIDs, muscle relaxants, opioids, or anti-inflammatory steroids during the Baseline Phase. Acetaminophen, at a dose of ≤ 1000 mg per day is acceptable;
able to discontinue the use of therapy defined as ice, heat, chiropractic care, physical therapy, acupuncture and acupressure on their lower back area during the Baseline Phase.

Exclusion Criteria:

open skin lesion within the painful area;
experiencing LBP for less than 3 months;
undergone back surgery within the past 3 months or has plans for back surgery within 30 days post-study;
participated in clinical treatment studies within 30 days of study entry;
chronic back pain which is due to fibromyalgia or connective tissue disorder (lupus, rheumatoid arthritis, ankylosing spondylitis, Reiter's syndrome, etc.);
LBP due to malignancy, vertebral fracture, or infection;
used opioids (including low potency/low dose opioid combinations and tramadol) more than 2 times per week within 30 days of study entry. Opioids and tramadol must not have been taken at least 4 days prior to study entry;
had injection therapy within 30 days of study entry, including corticosteroids;
a clinically significant psychiatric disorder (severe depression, other Axis I or Axis II disorders as defined in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th Edition (DSM-IV);
taking lithium, furosemide, and/or thiazides;
considered unreliable as to medication compliance (if any medication other than 1000 mg or less of acetaminophen a day was taken for any type of pain, the patient was discontinued) or adherence to scheduled appointments as determined by the investigators;
a prior history of GI bleeds/ulcers or clinically significant liver/kidney disease;
known hypersensitivity to flurbiprofen or other NSAIDs;
has a coagulation disorder or is taking warfarin or other anticoagulants (aspirin at a dose of [≤ 81 mg] is acceptable);
clinically significant fluid retention, cardiovascular disease (CVD), hypertension, or heart failure;
had coronary artery bypass graft surgery (CABG), cardiovascular thrombotic event, myocardial infarction (MI) and/or stroke within 1 year of Visit 1;
had unresolved litigation related to back injury or other pain complaints; settled disability claims/payments (Worker's Compensation, state/federal/private disability plans) were allowed.

Summary

Placebo Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

Placebo Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

All Events

Event Type Organ System Event Term Placebo Tape, Daily for 12 Hours Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 12 Hours Placebo Tape, Daily for 24 Hours Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

Cumulative Summed Pain Intensity Difference (SPID+)

The primary efficacy endpoint was the cumulative summed pain intensity difference (SPID+) at Days 4 and 7 of the tape treatment phase as computed from the daily categorical pain scale score reported on the patient's daily diary during the tape treatment phase; pain was rated on an 11-point scale, where: 0 = no pain, 10 = worst pain imaginable. Summed pain intensity difference is the sum of the pain intensity differences (PID). PID at each post-baseline evaluation was computed as the average baseline categorical pain scale score minus the post-baseline categorical pain scale score from the daily dairy. For patients with multiple pain scores reported on a given post-baseline study day, the PID scores were averaged to compute one daily PID score for each patient.

Placebo Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

SPID for Day 4

4.6
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 1.62

SPID for Day 7

8.4
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 2.95

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

SPID for Day 4

6.3
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 1.14

SPID for Day 7

12.1
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 2.06

Placebo Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

SPID for Day 4

6.7
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 1.56

SPID for Day 7

13.0
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 2.82

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

SPID for Day 4

5.2
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 1.13

SPID for Day 7

10.2
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 2.05

Pain Intensity Difference (PID+)

+PID = pre-treatment value at baseline - post-treatment value at day of evaluation, where: pre-treatment value at baseline = average daily pain over the last 3 days of the baseline phase (ie, average of daily averages of the categorical pain scale scores for the last 3 days of the baseline phase). Pain was rated on an 11-point scale, where: 0 = no pain, 10 = worst pain imaginable. A positive PID indicates a reduction in pain.

Placebo Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

Day 1

0.9
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.38

Day 2

1.4
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.46

Day 3

1.2
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.48

Day 4

1.1
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.49

Day 5

1.1
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.49

Day 6

1.2
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.50

Day 7

1.6
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.52

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

Day 1

1.3
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.26

Day 2

1.3
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.32

Day 3

1.6
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.34

Day 4

2.1
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.34

Day 5

1.7
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.34

Day 6

1.9
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.35

Day 7

2.2
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.36

Placebo Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

Day 1

1.1
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.36

Day 2

1.8
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.44

Day 3

2.0
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.46

Day 4

1.8
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.47

Day 5

2.1
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.47

Day 6

2.0
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.48

Day 7

2.2
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.49

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

Day 1

0.8
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.26

Day 2

1.4
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.32

Day 3

1.6
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.33

Day 4

1.4
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.34

Day 5

1.5
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.34

Day 6

1.5
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.35

Day 7

1.9
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 0.36

Average Daily Categorical Pain Scale Scores

Patients rated their lower back pain, caused by normal activity and movement, on an 11-point categorical pain scale, where: 0 = no pain, and 10 = worst pain imaginable. Patients rated their lower back pain every 12 hours, at any time they took medication including rescue medication for any type of pain, and if they applied or removed their treatment tapes at a time other than the scheduled time. Data are reported as the daily average categorical pain scale score by treatment group.

Placebo Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

Day 1

5.3
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.10

Day 2

4.7
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.37

Day 3

5.0
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.65

Day 4

5.0
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.57

Day 5

5.1
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.74

Day 6

4.9
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.78

Day 7

4.6
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.55

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

Day 1

4.8
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 1.92

Day 2

4.7
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 1.96

Day 3

4.5
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.04

Day 4

4.0
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.20

Day 5

4.4
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.56

Day 6

4.2
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.46

Day 7

3.8
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.33

Placebo Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

Day 1

5.3
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.18

Day 2

4.5
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.26

Day 3

4.3
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.36

Day 4

4.5
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.59

Day 5

4.2
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.38

Day 6

4.2
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.43

Day 7

4.1
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.50

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

Day 1

5.7
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 1.85

Day 2

4.9
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.51

Day 3

4.8
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.39

Day 4

5.0
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.54

Day 5

4.8
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.44

Day 6

4.8
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.60

Day 7

4.4
units on a scale (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 2.59

Percent Change From Baseline in Total Functional Rating Index (FRI)

Patients completed the FRI, a 10-item back pain-specific measure of function questionnaire describing the condition at the time the questionnaire was completed; each item (pain intensity, sleeping, personal care, travel, etc.) was rated on a 5-point scale, where 0 = best outcome, 4 = worst outcome. FRI was reported as the percent change from baseline at Day 7 of the tape treatment phase, where: Total FRI score = sum of the 10 questions. The total FRI score ranged from 0 (best outcome) to 40 (worst outcome). Percent change = ([baseline - Day 7]/baseline)*100. A positive percent change indicates a favorable treatment effect.

Placebo Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

20.6
percent change from baseline (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 7.40

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

29.0
percent change from baseline (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 5.10

Placebo Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

28.2
percent change from baseline (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 6.93

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

25.4
percent change from baseline (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 5.10

Change From Baseline in Total Tender Point Examination Score

At baseline and Day 7 of the tape treatment phase, patients had an assessment of tenderness bilaterally at the sacroiliac joint, greater trochanter of the hip, gluteus medius and minimus, and paraspinal muscles at L3-L4, L4-L5, and L5-S1. The investigator or research nurse pressed 12 specific areas of the body (6 locations, left and right sides), and patients were asked to rate the intensity of their pain at those 12 areas using an 11-point scale, where: 0 = no pain, 10 = the worst pain the patient has ever experienced. The total tender point examination score ranged from 0 (best outcome) to 120 (worst outcome). Change from baseline = baseline - Day 7. A positive change indicates a favorable treatment effect.

Placebo Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

13.9
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 4.40

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

11.7
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 3.03

Placebo Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

19.2
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 4.12

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

9.2
units on a scale (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 3.03

Patient Global Impression of Change (PGIC)

At Day 7, patients provided their PGIC with regard to lower back pain response to treatment, using a 7-point scale, where: 1 = very much improved, 7 = very much worse.

Placebo Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

1: Very much improved

3.0
participants

2: Much improved

1.0
participants

3: Improved

4.0
participants

4: No change

10.0
participants

5: Worse

1.0
participants

6: Much worse

7: Very much worse

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

1: Very much improved

7.0
participants

2: Much improved

10.0
participants

3: Improved

12.0
participants

4: No change

10.0
participants

5: Worse

2.0
participants

6: Much worse

7: Very much worse

Placebo Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

1: Very much improved

3.0
participants

2: Much improved

3.0
participants

3: Improved

8.0
participants

4: No change

8.0
participants

5: Worse

6: Much worse

7: Very much worse

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

1: Very much improved

9.0
participants

2: Much improved

4.0
participants

3: Improved

11.0
participants

4: No change

18.0
participants

5: Worse

6: Much worse

7: Very much worse

Acetaminophen Used During the Tape Treatment Phase

The percentage of patients who used rescue medication during the tape treatment phase.

Placebo Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

50.0
percentage of patients

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

54.8
percentage of patients

Placebo Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

36.4
percentage of patients

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

62.8
percentage of patients

Acetaminophen Used During the Tape Treatment Phase

The total amount (mg) of rescue medication used during the tape treatment phase.

Placebo Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

2226.9
mg (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 537.6

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

1617.5
mg (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 376.0

Placebo Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

1585.4
mg (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 515.2

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

2141.3
mg (Least Squares Mean)
Standard Error: 373.5

Percentage of Patients Who Discontinued

The percentage of patients who discontinued the study during the tape treatment phase due to lack of efficacy.

Placebo Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

2.4
percentage of patients who discontinued

Placebo Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

2.3
percentage of patients who discontinued

Patient Assessment of Wearability of Therapy

At Day 7, patients assessed the wearability of their treatment tape (ease of application, stays in place, comfortable to wear) using a 4-point scale, where: 1 = Excellent, 4 = Poor.

Placebo Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

Comfortable to wear, 1: Excellent

8.0
participants

Comfortable to wear, 2: Good

8.0
participants

Comfortable to wear, 3: Fair

Comfortable to wear, 4: Poor

3.0
participants

Ease of application, 1: Excellent

1.0
participants

Ease of application, 2: Good

5.0
participants

Ease of application, 3: Fair

5.0
participants

Ease of application, 4: Poor

8.0
participants

Stays in place, 1: Excellent

8.0
participants

Stays in place, 2: Good

3.0
participants

Stays in place, 3: Fair

5.0
participants

Stays in place, 4: Poor

3.0
participants

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

Comfortable to wear, 1: Excellent

18.0
participants

Comfortable to wear, 2: Good

14.0
participants

Comfortable to wear, 3: Fair

9.0
participants

Comfortable to wear, 4: Poor

Ease of application, 1: Excellent

1.0
participants

Ease of application, 2: Good

9.0
participants

Ease of application, 3: Fair

11.0
participants

Ease of application, 4: Poor

20.0
participants

Stays in place, 1: Excellent

16.0
participants

Stays in place, 2: Good

11.0
participants

Stays in place, 3: Fair

11.0
participants

Stays in place, 4: Poor

3.0
participants

Placebo Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

Comfortable to wear, 1: Excellent

9.0
participants

Comfortable to wear, 2: Good

8.0
participants

Comfortable to wear, 3: Fair

2.0
participants

Comfortable to wear, 4: Poor

3.0
participants

Ease of application, 1: Excellent

Ease of application, 2: Good

3.0
participants

Ease of application, 3: Fair

9.0
participants

Ease of application, 4: Poor

10.0
participants

Stays in place, 1: Excellent

6.0
participants

Stays in place, 2: Good

5.0
participants

Stays in place, 3: Fair

7.0
participants

Stays in place, 4: Poor

4.0
participants

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

Comfortable to wear, 1: Excellent

22.0
participants

Comfortable to wear, 2: Good

14.0
participants

Comfortable to wear, 3: Fair

2.0
participants

Comfortable to wear, 4: Poor

4.0
participants

Ease of application, 1: Excellent

3.0
participants

Ease of application, 2: Good

9.0
participants

Ease of application, 3: Fair

12.0
participants

Ease of application, 4: Poor

18.0
participants

Stays in place, 1: Excellent

10.0
participants

Stays in place, 2: Good

20.0
participants

Stays in place, 3: Fair

2.0
participants

Stays in place, 4: Poor

10.0
participants

Total

127
Participants

Age, Continuous

52.1
years (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 13.2

Sex: Female, Male

Overall Study

Placebo Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 12 Hours

Placebo Tape, Daily for 24 Hours

Flurbiprofen Tape, Daily for 24 Hours