Title

Comparing Vasopressin and Adrenaline in Patients With Cardiac Arrest
A Randomised, Double-blinded Multi-centre Trial Comparing Vasopressin and Adrenaline in Patients With Cardiac Arrest at the Emergency Department. (Preadmission Intravenous Vasopressin, Adrenaline Outcome Trial: PIVOT vII)
  • Phase

    Phase 3
  • Study Type

    Interventional
  • Study Participants

    727
The effectiveness of medications in cardiac arrest has been greatly debated and questioned. Historically intravenous adrenaline has been the drug of choice since 1906. There have been few formal evaluations to determine the value of adrenaline for cardiac arrest, and clinical trials have not been able to show any benefit with intravenous adrenaline (compared to placebo or no treatment) in the field.

Thus the purpose of this study is to compare vasopressin and adrenaline in the treatment of cardiac arrest to answer the question whether there is an improvement in survival between vasopressin and adrenaline.
The effectiveness of medications in cardiac arrest has been greatly debated and questioned. Historically intravenous adrenaline has been the recommended drug of choice since 1906. There have been few formal evaluations to determine the value of adrenaline for cardiac arrest, and clinical trials have not been able to show any benefit with intravenous adrenaline (compared to placebo or no treatment) in the field.

More recently, vasopressin has been used in patients with cardiac arrest. In human studies on vasopressin, clinical trials have produced conflicting results.

The current study compared vasopressin and adrenaline in the treatment of cardiac arrest in patients presenting to the Emergency Department (ED). Specific outcomes included return of spontaneous circulation (ROSC) (as measured by the presence of a palpable pulse at any time during resuscitation), survival to hospital admission, survival to discharge from hospital, and functional status at discharge and at one year (as measured by the Glasgow-Pittsburgh outcome categories).
Study Started
Mar 31
2006
Primary Completion
Jan 31
2009
Study Completion
Jan 31
2010
Results Posted
Aug 09
2011
Estimate
Last Update
Mar 17
2017

Drug Adrenaline

1 mg

  • Other names: Epinephrine

Drug Vasopressin

40 IU

  • Other names: Arginine vasopressin, argipressin, antidiuretic hormone

Adrenaline Active Comparator

Vasopressin Active Comparator

Criteria

Inclusion Criteria:

Patient with cardiac arrest as confirmed by the absence of a pulse, unresponsiveness and apnea
Age above 16 (Age 21 and above for CGH only)

Exclusion Criteria:

Traumatic cardiac arrest
Age 16 and below (Age 20 and below for CGH only)
CPR is contraindicated

Summary

Adrenaline

Vasopressin

All Events

Event Type Organ System Event Term

Survival to Hospital Discharge.

Survival to hospital discharge is defined as the patient leaving the hospital alive or survival to 30 days post cardiac arrest,whichever came first. This therefore measures the number of participants who was discharged alive or survived to 30 days post cardiac arrest, whichever came first.

Adrenaline

8.0
Participants

Vasopressin

11.0
Participants

Neurological Status on Discharge or at 30 Days Post Arrest, if Not Discharged.

Neurological status is assessed by the Glasgow-Pittsburgh outcome categories, to evaluate quality of life after successful resuscitation. Good neurological status is defined as cerebral performance categories(CPC)/overall performance categories(OPC):1 and 2.CPC/OPC 1 indicates good cerebral & overall performance. CPC/OPC 2 indicates moderate cerebral & overall disability. CPC/OPC 3 indicates severe cerebral & overall disability. CPC/OPC 4 indicates coma, vegetative state. CPC/OPC 5 indicates brain dead/death.

Adrenaline

Cerebral Performance Categories 1

5.0
Participants

Cerebral Performance Categories 2

Overall Performance Categories 1

2.0
Participants

Overall Performance Categories 2

3.0
Participants

Vasopressin

Cerebral Performance Categories 1

4.0
Participants

Cerebral Performance Categories 2

1.0
Participants

Overall Performance Categories 1

5.0
Participants

Overall Performance Categories 2

Neurological Status at 1 Year.

Neurological status is assessed by the Glasgow-Pittsburgh outcome categories, to evaluate quality of life after successful resuscitation. Good neurological status is defined as cerebral performance categories(CPC)/overall performance categories(OPC): 1 and 2. CPC/OPC 1 indicates good cerebral & overall performance. CPC/OPC 2 indicates moderate cerebral & overall disability. CPC/OPC 3 indicates severe cerebral & overall disability. CPC/OPC 4 indicates coma, vegetative state. CPC/OPC 5 indicates brain dead/death.

Adrenaline

Cerebral Performance Categories 1

5.0
Participants

Cerebral Performance Categories 2

Overall Performance Categories 1

3.0
Participants

Overall Performance Categories 2

2.0
Participants

Vasopressin

Cerebral Performance Categories 1

4.0
Participants

Cerebral Performance Categories 2

1.0
Participants

Overall Performance Categories 1

3.0
Participants

Overall Performance Categories 2

1.0
Participants

Return of Spontaneous Circulation.

Return of spontaneous circulation is defined as the presence of any palpable pulse detected by manual palpation of a major artery. This is measured as number of participants who had return of spontaneous circulation during resuscitation.

Adrenaline

106.0
Participants

Vasopressin

119.0
Participants

Survival to Admission.

Survival to admission is defined as the presence of pulse on admission to hospital (discharged from Emergency Department and admitted to Intensive Care Units /wards). This measures the number of participants with pulse and who were admitted to hospital.

Adrenaline

59.0
Participants

Vasopressin

83.0
Participants

Total

727
Participants

Age, Continuous

64.7
years (Mean)
Standard Deviation: 14.8

Age, Categorical

Region of Enrollment

Sex: Female, Male

Overall Study

Adrenaline

Vasopressin