Clinical Drug Experience Knowledgebase

Comparison of Efficacy and Safety of Intravenous Pulsed Methylprednisolone and Oral Methotrexate Versus Intravenous Pulsed Methylprednisolone and Oral Placebo in the Treatment of Active Moderate and Severe Thyroid Eye Disease - a Prospective, Randomized, Double-blind, Parallel, Controlled Multidisciplinary Clinical Trial and Imaging Study.

Since 1835 when Graves first described the eye changes in thyroid disease, considerable literature on investigating the basic disease process, the clinical behaviour, natural history and various medical and surgical treatments on thyroid orbitopathy has developed.

3.1 Pathogenesis 11, 12

HLA-DR histocompatibility loci which play a role in T-cell response have been associated with thyroid orbitopathy but no specific gene has been identified as yet.

It is believed that TSH receptors may be the autoantigen in Graves' hyperthyroidism, orbitopathy and pretibial myxoedema. Somehow, T-lymphocytes are activated and proceed to infiltrate orbital and other soft tissues. This sets off cytokine release which together with oxygen free radicals and fibrogenic growth factors leads to increased hydrophilic glycosaminoglycan (GAG) synthesis and pre-adipocyte transformation. The overall effect is an increase in orbital muscle and fat volume and inflammatory oedema which ultimately may result in muscle fibrosis and optic nerve compression.

3.2 Pathology

The histopathological features correlate with the immunogenetic theory in thyroid orbitopathy. The extraocular muscles are infiltrated by lymphocytes, macrophages, plasma cells and mast cells. Hydrophilic mucopolysaccharides are deposited and are seen separating the muscle bundles and fibres. In the later stages, fibrosis and muscle degeneration with fat replacement is noted.

3.3 Clinical Features

Based on literature review and the experience of the University of Columbia Orbital Clinic which saw over 2000 cases from 1976 to 2002.

Indices of disease activity (largely subjective)

Acuity of onset and progression

Acute (within a week) or subacute (3 months or under 3 months) or chronic onset (over 3 months)
Slow or rapid development (progression)

Subjective symptoms

Spontaneous retrobulbar pain
Pain on extraocular movement

Soft tissue features

- Swelling, injection and chemosis noted by the patient

Patient assessment of symptoms and signs - Same, better or worse

Indices of disease severity and extent (largely objective)

Lid and conjunctival swelling
Extraocular muscle function
Proptosis
Optic nerve function
Imaging changes in orbital tissues The NOSPECS classification of thyroid orbitopathy 13,14 does not give a clear picture of disease activity and severity. It does not guide prognostication and management and is thus abandoned in favour of the above assessment which looks specifically at indices which allow one to judge whether the disease is active and how severe it is 1.

From such an assessment, a treatment algorithm can be formulated:

3.4 Current Treatment

Although the exact aetiology and pathophysiology of thyroid orbitopathy remains unclear, what is known about the disease suggests an autoimmune mechanism at work 1,2. The initial phase of the disease is marked by clinical inflammatory changes and is followed by quiescence during which cicatricial and persistent orbital volume changes are more pronounced. In this latter phase, surgery alone works to alleviate symptoms. To avoid these end-stage developments, the disease should be treated during the active stage.

A recent trend in the management of thyroid orbitopathy has been to treat active disease with intravenous pulsed methylprednisolone 1,3-8. This step away from oral steroids arose from a desire to avoid the many known complications of prolonged oral steroid use as well as perceived lower success rates with the use of oral steroids. Marcocci et al 9 published in August 2001 results of a prospective, single-blind, randomized study that compared the effectiveness and tolerability of intravenous or oral glucocorticoids in association with orbital radiotherapy in the treatment of severe Graves' ophthalmopathy. This and other studies found that both treatments were effective (60-85% showing improvement) with the intravenous route associated with a lower rate of side effects. 3,4,5,6,7,9 Another treatment was reported by Smith and Rosenbaum in the British Journal of Ophthalmology 10. They described the use of oral methotrexate in the management of non-infectious orbital inflammatory disease. In their study, there were 3 patients with recalcitrant thyroid orbitopathy who had previously been treated with oral prednisolone, irradiation and surgical decompression. Two were still on oral prednisolone when oral methotrexate was started. All 3 showed clinical benefit and the 2 who were also on steroids initially were eventually able to cease steroid use. The good response may well be due to the fact that methotrexate, with its T-cell inhibiting effect, succeeded in halting the disease process especially when used together with corticosteroid.

The current treatment for those with progressively worse moderate or severe disease is medical decompression with either corticosteroid with or without cyclosporin or immunosuppressive agents such as methotrexate, cyclophosphamide or azathioprine as adjuvant therapy. The use of these latter agents are not well studied. When the soft tissue inflammation and orbital congestion is relieved, surgical redress of mechanical problems follows.

The role of radiotherapy remains unclear 15. Gorman et al conducted a prospective, randomized double-blind, placebo-controlled study of orbital radiotherapy for Graves' ophthalmopathy which failed to demonstrate any beneficial therapeutic effect 16. However, the study was flawed by the broad patient inclusion criteria and initiation of radiotherapy at different stages of the disease. Other studies have reported effective use of radiotherapy in the treatment of Graves' ophthalmopathy. Mourits conducted a randomized placebo-controlled trial which showed that external beam irradiation produced improvement in ocular motility in patients with mild or moderate disease 17.

We propose that active moderate and severe thyroid orbitopathy can be treated more aggressively with intravenous pulsed methylprednisolone and oral methotrexate in order to better stabilise the disease process and prevent cicatricial or compressive events. The question that this study aims to answer is whether this is a better treatment option compared to the current treatment in terms of efficacy and safety. Assessing the antibody and urinary GAG levels will yield information on serum and urinary profiles during treatment. We previously reported associations between thyroid autoantibodies and ophthalmopathy 18. The study will also use a 3-Tesla MRI to obtain normative values (MDI and PVR) for the Asian population and to evaluate quantitative changes in thyroid-related orbitopathy. This will provide a framework to study other multimodality therapy, including T-cell suppression, specific immunoglobulins and antifibroblastic agents.

4. STUDY PURPOSE

The purpose of this study is to investigate the effectiveness and safety of combined intravenous steroid and oral methotrexate in the treatment of patients with active moderate or severe thyroid orbitopathy. A prospective, randomized, double-blind, parallel, controlled clinical trial designed with this aim will provide useful information to aid future multimodality trials. This concept is based on the trend in managing rheumatologic disorders where early aggressive targeted multimodality therapy has improved treatment. The results of this study will also complement a planned radiotherapy study at the University of British Columbia